“PensionDanmark has a clear commitment to using its sustainable bonds strategy to drive progress towards a more sustainable economy,” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Denmark

Founded

1992

Type

Defined contribution

Members

416,800 (active)
57,700 (retired)

Assets

€44,000m

Performance

8% (1yr)

For many years, credit has been an important part of PensionDanmark’s asset allocation – constituting almost 20% of assets under management. It uses credit as a great substitute for equity risk in investments with shorter time horizons. Sustainability is deeply embedded in PensionDanmark’s operations, guiding investment decisions and risk management to align its investment portfolio with its long-term ESG goals.

All PensionDanmark’s credit portfolios today contain one or more forms of ESG-labelled bonds. However, the extent and types of investments vary across the various credit sub-asset classes. A particular focus for the team in the past few years has been sustainability-linked bonds (SLBs). These are bonds designed to incentivise issuers to achieve specific ESG targets. Unlike traditional labelled bonds, where funds are earmarked for specific sustainability projects, SLBs are tied to broader sustainability goals, including targets beyond environmental issues and factors.

An example of the strategy in practice is PensionDanmark investment in the first SLB issued by Italian utility group, ENEL in 2019, a bond said to be among the first in the world of its kind where the coupon adjusts in cases where ENEL fails to live up to certain greenhouse gas reduction targets. This investment is in line with PensionDamark’s decision in 2019 to create a dedicated portfolio for SLBs.

PensionDanmark believes that SLBs are occasionally criticised for not being truly green but it remains more positive towards the concept as it considers that the added flexibility it offers is both useful and meaningful in several sectors, where climate policies are much broader based and less specific to individual projects. This applies similarly to instances where issuers can use SLBs to demonstrate that they have committed climate policies to the entirety of their business, rather than only stand-alone projects. Danish wind turbine manufacturer Vestas is a good example of this.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ ESG-labelled bonds figure in all PensionDanmark’s credit portfolios

➤ Focus in recent years on sustainability-linked bonds (SLBs) that are linked to broader goals rather than individual projects

➤ Early investor in sustainable credit with portfolio created in 2019

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

France

AUM

€88,500m

Performance

Agirc-Arrco: 10.68%
General Fund: 2.80% (1yr)
Agirc-Arrco: 2.90%
General Fund: 2.14% (3yr)
Agirc-Arrco: 3.64%
General Fund: 2.04% (5yr)
Agirc-Arrco: 3.31%
General Fund: 2.40% (10yr)

AG2R La Mondiale’s sustainable bonds programme underlines its objective to ensure its ESG charter contributes to reconciling economic performance and its societal commitment by supporting companies and public entities that contribute to sustainable development, whatever their sector of activity. The sustainable bonds programme comprises 65% green bonds, 14% sustainable bonds, 6% sustainability-linked bonds and 15% social bonds. In the past 18 months, sustainable bonds have accounted for 14% of the volume of the group's bond purchases. They are analysed in the light of the SDGs that the issuers put forward. This dimension accounts for 50% of the final rating, alongside reporting and the issuer's ESG rating. The programme encompasses a diversified portfolio of 200 issuers of various jurisdictions, from France to Peru, and categories including governments, corporates, financial institutions and local authorities.

Judged by

Nicky Amos
Hanish Bhatia
Gianmaria Fragassi
Amlan Roy

Sponsored by