Small fund with big ambitions
WINNER
“Outstanding performance and a strong commitment to ESG, with innovative programmes to enhance contributions and stewardship," judge's comment.
Country |
Spain |
Founded |
1999 |
Type |
Hybrid of defined benefit and defined contribution |
Members |
3,098 active |
AUM |
€69m |
Performance |
9.79% (1yr) |
Established in 1999, Pensions Caixa 21’s assets are managed by insurance group VidaCaixa. The strategic asset allocation is 50% in fixed income securities in OECD countries, with a credit rating within VidaCaixa’s required parameters, and a target duration of three years. The remaining 50% is invested in global equities, mainly in regulated markets. Put options are used to hedge the equity portfolio against losses, an efficient strategy allowing the fund to enjoy the potential upside of a global bull market.
There is a target allocation of 10% for private equity assets, and to reduce the impact of the J-curve, Pensions Caixa 21 has made commitments at a significant discount in the secondary market, achieving a very positive performance. Co-investment funds have been introduced during the past year to provide greater expected returns with lower costs. Higher diversification is also achieved from infrastructure and private debt, which offer inflation-linked income or floating interest rates.
For over 20 years, Pensions Caixa 21 has integrated ESG into its investment decisions. VidaCaixa joined the Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) in 2009, the first Spanish insurance company to do so. Over the past year, it has improved ESG within its pre-trade analysis processes and monitoring, considering data from different sources. It runs sustainability training courses for steering committee members and employees and actively participates in stewardship initiatives such as engagement and voting.
Since 2016, the *Ahorra+mañana” (“Save more tomorrow”) programme has galvanised voluntary contributions from members. It provides for members whose salary has increased by more than the consumer price index (CPI) - mostly young people – to make a voluntary contribution of half the increase over the CPI. The percentage of individuals taking part has doubled from under 25% to over 50% of participants.
STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS
➤ Private equity commitments made at a discount to reduce the J-curve impact |
➤ Strong emphasis on ESG investing, stewardship initiatives and employee training |
➤ Programme increasing voluntary contributions via amounts linked to real-term salary increases |
HIGHLY COMMENDED
Country |
Spain |
AUM |
€188m |
Performance |
8.52% (1yr); |
Fondo de pensiones Empleados Deutsche Bank aims for high long-term returns through a diversified portfolio of between 50 and 70 large and mid-cap stocks in developed countries. It distinguishes itself from its peers by its ability to play medium-term trends, and by its systematic ESG approach within the investment process, increasing the reliability of asset manager decisions. Management of portfolio risk is professional, with issuers selected, and the portfolio monitored, by investment managers specialising in credit and country risk.
Country |
Spain |
AUM |
€6,759m |
Performance |
6.72% (1yr) |
The largest Spanish pension fund in terms of assets, Pensions Caixa 30 is recognised for its leading ESG policies, consistently ranking in the top 5% of Spanish funds for returns. In 2023, it reduced its carbon footprint by 2.9% for total portfolio emissions, while consistently delivering superior long-term returns. In its global equity portfolio, it has streamlined the approach to geographic model portfolio construction, reducing the number of funds from 17 to a more concentrated and conviction-driven selection of six funds, leading to a reduction in management costs.
Judged by
David Moreno
Pedro Pardo
Manuel Peraita
Frans Verhaar