Outside the public realm

“An innovative private markets investment strategy centred on ESG, with low management costs and high returns,” judge’s comment

WINNERS

Country

United Kingdom

Founded

2010

Type

Defined contribution

Members

12,500,000 active

Assets

€26,8000m

Performance

Nest 2040 Retirement Fund (default fund) -3.3 1-year to year end 31 March 2023; 6.2% 1-year to 30 June 2023 / Nest Ethical Fund 3.2% 1-year to 30 June 2023 / Nest Higher Risk Fund 5.7% 1-year to 30 June 2023 / Nest Sharia Fund 14.8% to 1-year 30 June 2023 / Nest Lower Growth Fund 0.5% 1-year to 30 June 2023
6.7% (3yr)
5.7% (5yr)
7.8% (10yr)

Set up in 2010 as part of the government automatic enrolment programme, Nest provides a DC workplace pension scheme to over 12m UK workers. It currently boasts £33bn (€37.8bn) of assets under management that is growing by £450m per month. ESG lies at the heart of its investment strategy: it believes that well-run organisations with sound environmental and social practices have a better chance of long-term success and profitability.

The first UK DC master trust to make a substantial commitment to private equity, Nest focuses on a growth strategy to provide capital to support unlisted companies in growing their operations. It identified this space as one which could provide attractive returns while deploying significant capital and avoiding many ESG and other risks associated with large leveraged buyouts. A key objective is to exert a more concentrated influence on the companies it invests in, improving ESG standards within the private equity world.

An innovative mandate structure which avoids paying performance fees and carried interest is used to manage the private equity allocation. Nest believes that performance fees detract from results and that without them, likely net returns will be at least as good, if not higher, providing high quality managers are [not clear]. Nest’s predictable and substantial capital commitments have allowed its managers to scale up their co-investment programme, gaining access to a wider range of attractive investment opportunities.

One barrier to DC schemes investing in this space is managing an allocation to highly illiquid assets within a default fund, or fund range, where members expect to see daily pricing and to be able to switch in or out when they please. Nest’s strong positive cashflows, very high participation in the default fund and creation of an internal market for trading illiquid investments between member funds means it can manage illiquidity and other operational risks.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Focus on improving ESG standards through enhanced influence on companies

➤ Innovative mandate structure avoiding performance fees and carried interest

➤ Ability to manage illiquid investments within a DC scheme

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Netherlands

AUM

€625,000m

Performance

-1.0% (1yr);
15.019% (3yr)
15.77% (5yr)
16.01(10yr)

APG’s €46bn private equity programme consists of three business verticals: primary funds, co-investments, and secondaries. The fund’s vertical is its main pipeline, leveraging general partner (GP) relationships to drive co-investments alongside its relationship with GPs. The secondaries programme benefits from market relationships to access value-accretive opportunities. One of the largest limited partners in fund investments, APG leverages its size to negotiate favourable fees and ESG requirements.

Country 

Denmark

AUM*

€41,000m

Performance)

–5.8% (1yr)
4.4% (3yr)
4.9% (5yr)
6.1% (10yr)

A frontrunner among European pension funds in private market investing, PensionDanmark was the first institutional investor worldwide to invest directly in offshore wind. Today, over 25% of its AUM is invested in private markets, primarily inhouse in private equity, private debt,  infrastructure and direct equity. PensionDanmark pursues opportunities where it has a comparative advantage and can add value. This has meant a tilt towards direct investments, hybrid structures and partnerships – a successful strategy, as its returns indicate.

Judged by

Stephan Kloess
Lisa Lafave
Milan Marinkovic
Jeroen Winkelman

Sponsored by