Right on target

“A prudent implementation of passive investment strategy together with the strong incorporation of ESG, using the targeting approach," judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Republic of North Macedonia

Founded

2005

Type

Defined benefit 
Industry-wide multi-employer pension funds

Members

279,000 active
30 retired

AUM

€1,087m

Performance

6.46% (1yr)
4.49% (3yr)
5.86% (5yr)
5.74% (10yr)

Established in 2005, KB First Pension Company (KB First) provides industrywide multi-employer retirement plans in the Republic of North Macedonia through two defined contribution schemes, one mandatory and one voluntary. The KB First Open Mandatory Pension Fund is currently in a high-growth accumulation phase of both assets and members. Assets under management have grown by almost 98% to €1.2bn over the past five years, with major outflows not expected until 2030. The average age of its members is 37, resulting in an average investment horizon of around 30 years.

KB First’s long-term investment objective is a return of 2 percentage points above inflation. Believing that international developed equities carry a higher volatility and therefore a higher potential return than other asset classes, it has built exposure to these investments to 30% - the legal maximum – out of a total equity allocation of 32%. It does this by using equity ETFs to minimise non-systemic risk and costs, while matching market performance.

Recently, KB First analysed the effects of implementing ESG principles in its portfolio – a big challenge, given its strategy of investing its equity allocation in ETFs. Based on the analysis, it decided to use a targeting approach. The goal was to improve the ESG score of the existing foreign equity portfolio to at least equal the ESG score of the MSCI ACWI ESG Universal Index, its chosen benchmark. KB First has since increased the ESG score of its foreign equities by 20% while decreasing its carbon intensity by 50%, while maintaining a similar risk/return profile. This resulted in a return on foreign equities higher than before ESG was implemented; its total return for 2023 was 6.46%, giving an average return of 5.74% for the past ten years.

KB First has also begun to diversify into ETFs concentrating on artificial intelligence (AI), not only reflecting its commitment to sustainable investing but also positioning it at the forefront of innovation.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ High-growth accumulation phase reflecting relatively young membership

➤ Increase of 20% in ESG score for foreign equity ETFs, with improved financial return

➤ Sustainability and innovation through investment in ETFs focusing on artificial intelligence

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Belgium

AUM

€388m

Performance

BE DB section: 12.09%
BE DC section: 16.10%
Dutch section: 11.27%
Pension Fund: 12.40% (1yr)
1.89% for Belgium DB
-0.97% for the Netherlands (3yr)
3.59% for Belgium DB
2.77% for the Netherlands (5yr)

Euroclear Pension Fund is gradually adopting an ESG approach to investments, while maintaining its passive management philosophy. Starting with the global equity portfolio within the fund’s DB segments, it is setting up a new benchmark and global equity mutual fund, advised by Impact Cubed, a firm dedicated to ESG for institutional investors. This means underweighting/overweighting stocks of low-ESG /high-ESG issuers, which in turn will increase/decrease the cost of capital of these issuers, incentivising them to become more sustainable.

Country 

Sweden

Assets

€44,883m

Performance

9.6% (1yr)
4.80% (3yr)
8.95% (5yr)
8.50% (10yr)

Fjärde AP-fonden (AP4) integrates climate strategies across all investments in its global equity portfolio, tailoring them to the specific conditions of different sectors. It focuses on high-emission sectors, including energy, power generation, raw materials and transport. It selects companies which are expected to outperform their benchmark indices and contribute to the energy transition. For other sectors, it selects companies using quant-based equity strategies. These approaches have reduced the portfolio’s carbon emissions by over half since 2012.

Judged by

Christoph Gort
Sylvie Malécot
Joseph Mariathasan
Michel Piermay

Sponsored by