Defender of the realm

“Outstanding long-term performance and convincing strategy – makes good use of its long-term investment horizon and regulatory scope” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Sweden

Founded

1974

Type

Sovereign reserve fund

Members

5,000,000 active

Assets

€41,260m

Performance

-11.9% (1yr)
4.8% (3yr)
6.9% (5yr)
8.92% (10yr)

As at 31 December 2022

Fjärde AP-fonden's (AP4) long-term perspective starts with its ALM study, which it reviews every three years and was updated in 2023. Because of the strong balance sheet and a diminishing remaining period of outflows from the system, it is better to lower the expected return slightly than to increase the risk level in the investment portfolio. These assessments have led to the decision to keep AP4’s long-term real return target over 40 years at 3.5%.

● In 2022, AP4 introduced a new asset class, defensive equities, to its dynamic normal portfolio (DNP), the benchmark portfolio used for operative asset management. The new category makes up 5% of the DNP, funded from fixed income and global equities. These stocks are weighted differently from a market-weighted index to add return potential and provide stabilising characteristics in markets where the probability of negative scenarios has risen. This brought success in 2022, when AP4’s global equities portfolio lost 19%, while defensive equities fell by under 4%.

● AP4 has taken full advantage of new regulations allowing increased allocations to illiquid real assets. The asset class has increased from 12% of fund capital in 2019 to 18% today. In 2019, this exposure came mainly from real estate, but the ensuing increase was largely in new investments in infrastructure. The reallocation is part of a planned change to increase exposure to long-term stable real cashflows through diversification.

● AP4 is continuously analysing sustainability trends, searching for investment opportunities in this area which also provide a high long-term financial return. An extensive update of its thematic analysis, completed in early 2023, identified five main investment themes: fossil phase-out in energy systems, cleaner industry, fossil-free transport, thriving biospheres and green buildings and infrastructure. Over the past three years, AP4 has invested or committed €2.5bn within these activities.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Designation of defensive equities as new asset class

➤ Increased allocations to illiquid real assets, improving diversification

➤ Continuous search for sustainable investment opportunities providing enhanced financial returns

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Denmark

AUM

€29,200m

Performance

-6.5% (1yr);
6.5% (10yr)

Working systematically on return/risk optimisation and efficient inflation protection, Industriens Pension has built a robust portfolio, achieving the highest long-term return among Danish pension funds. A major contributor is relatively high allocations to credit markets and other alternatives, providing very high diversification and lower realised volatility compared with the fund’s Danish peers.

Country 

United Kingdom

AUM*

€38,028m

Performance)

1.9% (1yr) (growth assets)
3.09% (5yr)

The Pension Protection Fund boasts a unique, market-leading approach to LDI, recalibrating liabilities in its matching portfolio every week. It has also gradually reduced its LDI leverage, so when other funds faced acute funding stresses in September/October 2022, it was able to honour collateral calls without being forced to sell growth assets.

Country 

Spain

AUM*

€6,396m

Performance)

–7.61% (1yr)
3.48% (3yr)
4.08% (5yr)

A pioneer in setting local standards for investment governance, Pensions Caixa 30 (PC30) has focused on sustainability in its strategic plan for 2021-23. This includes monthly monitoring of ESG and climate-related metrics and mapping out a carbon journey plan for reaching net zero emissions by 2050.

RISING STAR

Country 

Spain

AUM*

€6.8m

Performance)

–18.67% (1yr)
0.65% (3yr)
0.62% (5yr)
5% (10yr)

Caja de Ingenieros Empleo’s overall goal is to achieve maximum long-term returns with strict control of risk through investment in equities, where it invests a maximum of 70% of its assets in companies with sound fundamentals and sustainable levels of leverage and growth. The remaining assets are invested in fixed income securities from issuers with a low level of leverage, stable credit ratings and a proven ability to pay coupons.

Judged by

Roland van den Brink
Dorothee Franzen
Christian Böhm
Thomas Post