A smooth operator running on auto
WINNER
“Great idea to use the smoothing mechanism that takes some of the best from both the individual and collective worlds,” judge’s comment
Country |
Ireland |
Founded |
1972 |
Type |
Hybrid of defined benefit and defined contribution |
Members |
3,401 active |
AUM |
€1,324m |
Performance |
11.50% (1yr) |
The GMS Superannuation Plan for self-employed general practitioners aims to deliver DB-style benefits while offering DC-style flexibility. Its long-term performance target is CPI + 4% p.a. and its average return over the past ten years is 6.6% p.a.
Its distinctive feature is the pioneering smoothing mechanism, which averages investment returns over a four-year period to cushion members from short-term market fluctuations. It also allows members to remain invested in growth assets for longer, instead of derisking too early, and can lead to higher retirement pots. The predictability of returns generated has fostered a high level of confidence among members.
The Plan declares an annual bonus for active and deferred members, designed to reflect the smoothed performance of the portfolio. The bonus aims to ensure that the minimum return declared each year is non-negative. This does not guarantee a specific rate of return but significantly reduces the likelihood of members experiencing a negative return in any year.
STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS
➤ Hybrid scheme offering DB-style benefits with DC-style flexibility |
➤ Smoothing mechanism averaging returns over a four-year period to protect against volatility |
➤ Annual bonus aiming to ensure the minimum return each year is not negative |
WINNER
“A leader in communicating with participants, taking important positions on wider issues including auto-enrolment and gender parity,” judge’s comment
Irish Life’s defined contribution offerings include 40 standalone schemes and the EMPOWER Master Trust, which boasts a robust governance structure and a comprehensive range of funds. Members can access digital tools giving them the ability to retain existing scheme records online, ensuring a seamless transition if they are transferring from elsewhere.
Education is a fundamental component of Irish Life’s offering. Its member engagement programme guides individuals through their retirement journey, with webinars and videos to help them understand the basics;at retirement, it offers one-to-one sessions. With the arrival of auto-enrolment, Irish Life has also launched the Auto Ease proposition for employers, alongside a suite of informative guidelines to help them manage the introduction of auto-enrolment in their workplace pension scheme.
A trailblazer on gender pension parity, Irish Life has run several campaigns to ensure women are aware of the gender gap in pensions, suggesting ways to close it.
STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS
➤ Strong emphasis on education, with webinars, videos and one-to-one sessions |
➤ New development to help employers introduce auto-enrolment |
➤ Ongoing campaign to close the gender pension gap |
HIGHLY COMMENDED
Country |
Ireland |
AUM |
€262m |
Performance |
7.10% (1yr) |
In 2011, combined assets of the Musgrave Limited Pension Scheme’s DB plan were €265m, but with a €191m deficit and an average funding level of 58%. To tackle this, it formed a special committee to oversee investment decisions, improve risk management and create cost efficiencies. With a highly diversified investment strategy, encompassed with a market-aware de-risking plan, its asset allocation was transformed over time to more closely match the scheme’s liabilities. This strategy has increased the funding level to its current 94%.
Judged by
Nora Finn
Helen Kobæk
Eugene O'Callaghan
Kiemthin Tjong Tjin Joe
Sponsored by