Forging ahead with expansion plans

“An excellent alternatives investments strategy, great performance and outstanding monitoring.” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Germany

Founded

2002

Type

Hybrid of defined benefit and defined contribution

Members

165,000 (active, including deferred)
45,000 (retired)

Assets

€5,770m

Performance

-9.6% (1yr)
2.4% (3yr)
3.7% (5yr)
5.3% (10yr)

The €5.8bn Bosch Pensionsfonds (BPF) caters for 210,000 members. Despite a 9.6% loss on its investment portfolio in 2022, this followed a 14% gain in 2021 and the pension fund has performed well over the long term, generating an average annual return of 5.3% over the past decade.

BPF has steadily increased its stake in alternatives since 2008, with a portfolio now spanning private equity, infrastructure, private debt and real estate. Last year, rigorous manager selection and a proactive approach led to a 9.9% return from its alternative investment allocation, offsetting the losses incurred on listed assets. In 2022, the pension fund added 11 more assets to its alternatives portfolio, with the allocation valued at €2.4bn at the end of the year. Almost all BPF’s assets in this area outperformed expectations, a testament to the pension fund’s strong manager selection process.

BPF has developed a pioneering reporting and monitoring system for its alternatives portfolio to counteract the lack of publicly available data on this asset class. The bespoke reporting system covers seven ‘dimensions’ and 30 underlying qualitative and quantitative review criteria to identify potential areas for improvement. This system is also designed to improve dialogues with asset managers and create a benchmark for future assessments and negotiations with other stakeholders. The fund anticipates further growth and innovation, including the integration of ESG considerations. It plans to hire new staff to support these efforts.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Busy 2022 with 11 new assets added to the alternatives portfolio

➤ Increased investment in private debt to benefit from attractive risk-return profiles

➤ Substantially enhanced reporting systems to support transparency, manager dialogue and member communication

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Germany

AUM

€3,000m

Performance

 

The €3bn HVB Pension Fund has recently overhauled its liability-driven investment (LDI) strategy with the aim of reducing funding volatility. HVB has also made changes to its sustainability strategy, including incorporating ESG considerations into the LDI strategy. It uses the UN Sustainable Development Goals to provide a framework for private markets investment and has developed a ‘Smart Low Carbon Factor Strategy’ combining factor investing with sustainability considerations.

Country 

Germany

AUM*

€15,708m

Performance)

–6.9% (1yr)
6.4% (3yr)
4.4% (5yr)
6.3% (10yr)

Ärtzeversorgung Westfalen-Lippe (ÄVWL) advocates an active approach to managing its liquid investments. This involves what it calls a ‘magic triangle’, balancing profitability, security and liquidity. This led to a build-up of assets in money market funds, which served to protect the fund from volatility in bond markets. It reinvested this liquidity into Europe and emerging markets, as well as equities to benefit from emerging opportunities. It also allocated to new structured bonds and absolute return mandates./em>

Judged by

Hermann Aukamp
Alex Koriath
Manfred Kupka
Edwin Meysmans

Sponsored by