Finding another way

“A pioneer of alternative investments for DC/hybrid plans, with strong governance and an investment process matching global best practice,” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Germany

Founded

2002

Type

Hybrid corporate pension fund

Members

135,000 (active)
47,000 (retired)
32,000 (deferred)

AUM

€6,670m

Performance

10.7% (1yr)
4.5% (3yr)
6.9% (5yr)
5.7% (10yr)

Bosch Pensionsfonds (BPF) was founded in 2002, but with over 210,000 beneficiaries, increasing complexity, and a projected doubling of its €6.7bn portfolio in the next ten years, it saw that a major leap forward was needed to accelerate its development. It therefore developed a strategy to make BPF more flexible and effective, future-proofing its position.

To ensure sustainable investment success, BPF decided to expand activities in alternative asset classes. By exploiting the entire spectrum from private and infrastructure equity through to private corporate debt and real estate, its portfolio now combines high return opportunities with relatively low volatility, allowing it to consistently outperform expectations. The creation of a dedicated inhouse team and a meticulous manager selection process have been crucial in achieving this impressive track record.

Aiming to enhance transparency as well as effective monitoring and steering, BPF has developed a groundbreaking bespoke reporting system tailored specifically for its alternative investments. Backed by almost thirty review criteria across seven critical dimensions, it provides unparalleled insights to assess the progress of each investment, identifying potential areas for improvement. Reporting results have empowered the inhouse team to engage in meaningful dialogue with managers, providing benchmarks to strengthen negotiating positions.

BPF has earned a reputation for its exceptional risk management capabilities, with innovations such as its fund-based pension (“Fondsrente”) -- typically offering retirees a higher income than a lifetime annuity -- and its internally developed management system consisting of retroactive and predictive reporting supported by a sophisticated traffic light algorithm. All risk management activities are overseen by a dedicated risk manager.

BPF recently launched its “excellent member service” to reach unparalleled service levels by regarding the member as the most important stakeholder. An already resilient administration was transformed into a member-centric unit, with processing times and accessibility defined by the expectations and specific needs of members.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Expansion of alternative assets with inhouse team, meticulous manager selection and groundbreaking reporting system

➤ Bespoke risk management system using a sophisticated traffic light algorithm

➤ Member service levels boosted to reflect beneficiaries’ status as most important stakeholders

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Ireland

AUM

€1,324m

Performance

11.50% (1yr);
5.70% (3yr)
7.60% (5yr)
6.60% (10yr)

General Medical Services Superannuation Plan is uniquely designed for self-employed general practitioners, aiming to deliver DB-type benefits with DC-type flexibility. Its innovative smoothing mechanism is analogous, and it considers this superior to DC life-styling, with investment returns averaged over a four-year period to cushion members from short-term market fluctuations.

Country 

Sweden

AUM

€83,610m

Performance)

16.7% (1yr)

The Swedish Fund Selection Agency aims to increase its funds’ average annual return after costs by 50 basis points, without changing the overall risk level. To achieve this, it has tailored its procurement process by identifying high-quality funds, obtaining competitive pricing from managers, and emphasising the fund managers’ operational due diligence.

Country 

Iceland

AUM

€2,766m

Performance

13.30% (1yr)

Almenni Pension Fund offers loans to members, secured on a real estate mortgage. Indexed and non-indexed loans are available with fixed interest rates for 36 months, and variable interest rates thereafter, unless the borrower fixes the interest rate again. Having taken out a loan, fund members can view its status online at any time.

Judged by

Melanie Durrant
Philippos Mannaris
Chris Sier
Waltraud Viehböck