Shifting benchmarks

“The overall investment governance, focus on risk management and dynamic use of alternatives suggests a strong oversight model that delivers,” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Germany

Founded

2002

Type

Hybrid corporate pension fund

Members

124,000 (active)
45,000 (retired)
31,000 (deferred)

Assets

€5,770m

Performance

-9.6% (1yr)
2.4% (3yr)
3.7% (5yr)
5.3% (10yr)

Bosch Pensionsfonds (BPF) has always been closely attuned to the markets, adapting swiftly to new trends. This has helped it navigate the Ukraine war, pandemic and rising interest rates, which caused a major market correction in 2022.

BPF’s fixed income (FI) portfolio is diversified on two levels: geographically, and by credit quality, from government to high-yield bonds. It is also a balanced combination of passive and active mandates. BPF’s absolute return strategies aim to deliver attractive risk-adjusted returns independent of markets by investing in a broad range of FI securities.

To achieve this, in 2022, about 25% of the BPF’s FI volume was invested in absolute return mandates. This diversification proved advantageous, with BPF restricting losses on the portfolio to single digits. The portfolio benefited from low duration absolute return bond mandates, some of which yielded returns as high as 2.1%.

BPF has increased its alternatives allocation from 17.5% to 21%, as a result of an asset-liability modelling analysis carried out by its fiduciary manager. The analysis also revealed the increasing importance of private debt; consequently BPF extended its allocation to this asset class to 29% of its alternatives portfolio. This has allowed it to capitalise on variable interest rates offered in private debt. In last year’s difficult market environment, BPF delivered a 9.9% return across its alternative investments, with a double-digit annual performance since inception.

Having long benefited from its absolute return mandates, BPF has decided to transition to benchmark mandates with longer durations, allowing it to efficiently leverage the favourable interest rate environment. The synergy between its FI and alternatives portfolios will significantly help bolster overall performance and mitigate losses. Furthermore, BPF has already started reviewing whether an LDI strategy is appropriate going forward and is hiring additional talents to capitalise on future opportunities inhouse.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Highly diversified fixed income portfolio, with balanced active/pssive management

➤ Expansion of alternatives allocation, particularly in private markets

➤ Planned transition to longer duration benchmark mandates leveraging favourable interest rates

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Spain

AUM

€592m

Performance

-6.3% (1yr);
1.67% (3yr)
2.16% (5yr)

In 2022, the board of GM Pensiones (GMP) adjusted its investment strategy, seizing short-term opportunities brought by higher interest rates while pursuing a long-term target. The fund increased investments in alternative credit fixed income, balancing the resulting higher risk by reducing equity exposure to neutral. It also increased exposure to long-term debt, while US dollar assets were diversified in favour of yen and sterling. While incurring a negative investment return for 2022, GMP was the best performer of the top ten Spanish corporate pension funds.

Country 

Iceland

AUM

€2,690m

Performance)

Life Portfolio I: -14.5%, Life Portfolio II: -13%, Life Portfolio III: -7.9%, Gov. Bond Portfolio: -12%, Savings Account Portfolio: 0%, Mortgage Portfolio: -1.8%; Mutual Insurance Fund: -12.7% (1yr)
Life Portfolio I: 1.3%, Life Portfolio II: 0.1%, Life Portfolio III: -0.8%, Gov. Bond Portfolio: -4.7%, Savings Account Portfolio: 0%, Mortgage Portfolio: -0.7%; Mutual Insurance Fund: -0.4% (3yr)
Life Portfolio I: 4.9%, Life Portfolio II: 3.6%, Life Portfolio III: 1.6%, Gov. Bond Portfolio: -0.7%; Savings Account Portfolio: 0.6%, Mortgage Portfolio: 0.6%; Mutual Insurance Fund: 3.1%(5yr)
Life Portfolio I: 4.6%, Life Portfolio II: 4%, Life Portfolio III: 2.5%, Gov. Bond Portfolio: 1.3%; Savings Account Portfolio: 1%; Mutual Insurance Fund: 3.7% (10yr)

Almenni Pension Fund offers a unique split of contributions between a mutual insurance scheme (8.5% of the 15.5% mandatory contribution) and a private account (7% of the mandatory contribution). Members choose between six portfolios for their private accounts: three Life Portfolios (with varying mixes of equities and bonds), and three investing in bonds and/or bank deposits. Since 1990, the average annual real return of the mutual insurance fund has been 4.4%, while Life Portfolio II (55% equities, 45% bonds) has returned 4.1% per year in real terms.

Judged by

Heribert Karch
Philippos Mannaris
Sergio Miguez
Waltraud Viehböck

Sponsored by