Walking a different path

“Great performance with an innovative asset allocation approach - a smaller fund that goes the extra mile to outdo the giants” judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Switzerland

Type

Hybrid corporate pension fund

Members

5,656 active, 
3,744 retired

Assets

€1,818m

Performance

–4.98% (1yr)
4.02% (3yr)
4.14% (5yr)
5.12% (10yr)

As at 31 December 2022

Pensionskasse Manor (Manor) is a hybrid pension scheme for employees of a Swiss family-owned corporate group, with 9,400 members and €1.8bn in assets. Mirroring the business, the pension fund has adopted an entrepreneurial approach to its investment strategy. It started reducing its bond exposure sharply in 2013 to its current level of 5.5% of assets. The proceeds have mostly been reinvested in alternative assets including private markets, hedge funds, private equity and infrastructure, with impressive results. The biggest component of the fund’s alternatives allocation is currently hedge funds (14%), followed by private equity (5%), infrastructure (3.5%) and gold (2.5%).

● The fund’s approach is probably closer to that of US endowments than to other Swiss pension funds. It considers that this divergence is courageous, but only possible with education, conviction and the full support of its board of directors. Over the past ten years, Manor has used its alternatives portfolio to build a fixed income proxy, with convincing results. Studies show this approach clearly pays, with solid net performance over this period. There has also been a very positive effect on Manor’s coverage ratio, which at 123.9% is among Switzerland’s highest.

● As a consequence, Manor was able to increase retirement benefits by 2% at the beginning of 2023, giving some protection against inflation. Over the past five years, active members have also received annual interest payments of 3.05% - a fair amount, given the negative interest rates in Switzerland over the period.

● Determined to avoid complacency, Manor is preparing a new asset/liability management study to reposition its strategic asset allocation. It does not intend to change its approach completely, but an increase in its fixed income allocation is a possibility.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Innovative approach to investment, replacing bond holdings with alternatives

➤ Annual interest payments of 3.05% to active members over past five years

➤ ALM study planned as basis for repositioning strategic asset allocation

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Bosch Pensionfonds (BPF) has increased private debt to 29% of its alternatives allocation, after an ALM study underlined the favourable risk return profile of this asset class. The target allocation for alternatives overall has also been increased from 17.5% to 21%. Pioneering the concept of standardised reporting, BPF has developed a tailored monitoring report specifically for alternatives. Backed by almost 30 qualitative and quantitative review criteria across seven critical dimensions, this will assess the progress and performance of each investment, identifying potential areas for improvement.

Country 

Belgium

AUM*

€1,645m

Performance)

–12.6% (1yr)
0.4% (3yr)
3% (5yr)
5.7% (10yr)

An early mover among Belgian pension funds in embracing local unlisted infrastructure investment, Pensioenfonds Metaal [PM] has built a portfolio which is diversified across sectors and regions, providing opportunities for attractive risk-adjusted returns. Infrastructure now amounts to €255m, or 15% of total assets. Working alongside Belgian infrastructure investor PMV, PM has actively contributed to the growth of local communities in Belgium, fostering economic progress and creating employment opportunities. It also invests in diverse European infrastructure projects with other partners.

Judged by

Alan Briefel
Théodore Economou
Nereida González López
Philip Menco