Top picks

“Clear analysis of comparative advantages, well-argued home markets bias, and extremely low total costs, with consistently excellent performance over all time periods," judge’s comment

WINNER

Country

Sweden

Founded

1974

Type

Sovereign reserve and buffer funds

Members

5,200,000 active

Assets

€44,883m

Performance

9.6% (1yr)
4.8% (3yr)
8.95% (5yr)
4.86% (10yr)

As at 31 December 2023

Celebrating its 50th anniversary this year, AP4 can boast an average return of 13% per annum since inception, and assets of SEK533bn (€46.2bn) at 30 June 2024, at which date it had transferred a total SEK58bn into the Swedish public pension system in its role as a provider of liquidity.

AP4’s purpose in supporting the Swedish pension system means that it has a very long investment horizon, of up to 40 years. This provides unique opportunities to manage volatility for the benefit of higher returns, while maintaining the fund’s resilience. AP4 therefore holds a significant equity allocation made up of global equities (39%) and domestic equities (16%), as well as real assets (16%), including real estate and infrastructure, with the rest almost wholly in fixed income.

Based on an assessment showing that internal management can achieve equal or better returns after costs than can outsourcing, 79% of AP4’s assets were managed internally, and 21% externally, as of December 2023. The size of AP4’s assets under management allow for economies of scale without restricting investment opportunities; management costs are currently 0.08% of net assets.

AP4 believes that its active management of equities enhances long-term real returns. Given its comparative advantages in different markets, several different routes are used to achieve this:

  • Global equities are run as structured alpha-beta separation, where beta and risk factors, such as sustainability, are managed cost-efficiently inhouse.
  • External long-short equity market neutral hedge funds provide cost-efficient risk-adjusted alpha.
  • The alpha-beta separation strategy is complemented in emerging markets by long-only managers with a focus on different sustainability themes.
  • For Swedish equities, AP4 exploits its local knowledge and the ability to influence the companies that it invests in as a long-term owner. The relatively large allocation reflects Sweden’s strong economic fundamentals.

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAYS

➤ Large equity allocations allowing active management benefiting from economies of scale

➤ Global equities run as structured alpha-beta separation

➤ Local knowledge and long-term influence over companies to create value in domestic investments

HIGHLY COMMENDED

Country 

Germany

AUM

€6,670m

Performance

10.7% (1yr)
4.5% (3yr)
6.9% (5yr)
5.7% (10yr)

Last year, Bosch Pensionsfonds used its active management approach to seize exceptional market opportunities in private equity secondaries, following an in-depth analysis by its private markets adviser. Challenging market conditions, including low liquidity and high selling pressure, allowed the fund to tap into a well-established market at attractive prices to unlock additional value.

Country 

Spain

AUM

€188m

Performance

8.52% (1yr)
4.74% (3yr)
5.78% (5yr)
4.86% (10yr)

The investment portfolio of Fondo de pensiones Empleados Deutsche Bank is actively managed using a fundamental approach for stock selection. There is a preference for the large capitalisation universe, with the fund directly invested in bonds and stocks. All asset classes are subject to a sustainability assessment.

Country 

Republic of North Macedonia

Assets

€997m

Performance

Mandatory fund 8.11%, voluntary fund 8.46% (1yr) Mandatory fund 4.90%, voluntary fund 5.30% (3yr) Mandatory fund 5.45%, voluntary fund 5.59% (5yr) Mandatory fund 5.66%, voluntary fund 5.94% (10yr)

Sava pension company a.d. Skopje uses a top-down approach when setting tactical asset allocations between asset classes and geographies, contrasting with a bottom-up approach in actively managing domestic equities. The strategy focuses on detecting and selecting long-term market winners, including defining long-term trends. Active management also extends to execution costs, tax efficiency and integrating ESG.

Judged by

Karin Kisling
Eugene O'Callaghan
Amlan Roy
Stephan Skaanes

Sponsored by