Judging

Comprising chiefly investment consultants, academics and former pension fund executives from across Europe, the IPE Awards judges are specially chosen according to their region and/or area of expertise. Up to 100 judges can be involved in the IPE Awards.
 
Judging involves a two-stage review process for all the categories except the country/regional awards and is completely transparent.
The judges make use of IPE's online entry system to review and score the entries.  Each judging panel features at least four judges. For the Outstanding Industry Contribution and Pension Fund Achievement of the Year, we invite all the judges to vote on the short-listed candidates. .
 
The first phase of the judging process invites members of each judging panel to read and score the entries according to a 20-point score matrix that ranks each against its peers, nationally, regionally and globally. We calculate an average of the judges’ scores to produce the ranking in each category. This gives us the country and regional Awards winners.
 
For the themed, bronze, silver and gold awards, if the result is too close to call, we will call a second stage of judging that invites members of each judging panel to join a discussion on the results of the first round of judging of the relevant category. The judges may revise their score during or after the discussion. If need be, we then recalculate the averages and agree the winners. We will call a debate by default for the European Pension Fund of the Year category, regardless of the result of the first round of judging.  
 
It is inevitable in a business such as ours that conflicts of interest can occur at the judging stage. We rely on our judges to make sure that such factors do not influence their views and we are happy that our judges act with honesty and integrity. Were a serious conflict to emerge, however, any judge may excuse themselves from judging a particular entry. In this instance, we would take an average of the other judges' scores in that panel to generate the conflicted judge's score. 
 
If there are pension funds with equal top scores, IPE is happy to present the award to both as joint winners.
 
The judges’ view is final and no correspondence or contact between judges and entrants is entertained.

2016 Judges

Jon 
Mats 
Hermann 
Pedro 
Edward 
Xavier
Silvio
David 
Ed
Mary 
Richard 
Andrew 
David
Trevor 
Adrian
Douglas
Tim 
Jeroen
Mark 
Frederic
Oliver
Rudyard
Wolfgang 
Benoit 
Patrick 
Flavio
Nora 
Astrid
Felix 
Karel 
Ger
Sophie 
Adina 
Gaudencio
Bernd
Neill 
Casper 
Bart 
Lars
Andreas 
Haitse
Georg 
John
James 
Cem
Ravi 
Karin
Stephan
Torsten
Felix 
Peter 
Morten 
Stefan 
David 
Graziano
Anne
Philippos
Joseph 
Neil 
Mike 
Philip 
Alvaro
Gerald 
Gerard 
Andrea
Russell C.
Michel 
Jean-François
Claudio 
Ignasi
Olli
Amin
Michel
Nick
Claus 
Bob 
Raj
Geert Jan
Sotiris 
Benny
Murat 
Richard 
Anton
Martine 
Waltraud
Kristof 
Aldecoa
Andersson
Aukamp
Barbosa
Barker
Bellavista
Bencini
Bennett 
Britton
Cahill
Campbell
Chapman 
Cienfuegos
Cook
Cooper
Crawshaw
Currell
de Soete 
de Vijs  
Debaere
Draeger
Ekindi
Ettl
Fally
Ferguson
Fidani
Finn
Gambihler
Goltz
Goossens
Goris
Grenier
Grigroiu
Guedes
Haferstock
Hamilton
Hammerich 
Heenk
Hermann
Hoepner
Hoos
Inderst 
Jones
Kavanagh
Kaya
Khanna
Kisling
Kloess
Koepke
Kottmann
Kraneveld 
Linde Soerensen
Lundbergh
Lunsford
Lusenti
Maher
Mannaris
Mariathasan
McPherson
McShee
Menco
Molina De Porres
Moore
Moritz
Nanni
PIcot
Piermay
Pinçon
Pinna
Puigdollers
Pusa
Rajan
Salden
Samuels
Skadhauge
Swarup
Thamotheram
Troost
Tsolacos
Tuomolin
Uenal
Urban 
Van Nunen
van Peer
Viehboeck
Woutters
Novaster
Former CEO of AP4 
Independent - formerly with NAEV
PEB
Zanders
Mercer
European Investment Consulting
Redington
Willis Towers Watson
Aon Hewitt
Towers Watson
Independent - former CIO of the Health Foundation
Willis Towers Watson
SPS Conferences
Barnett Waddingham LLP
Towers Watson
Aon Hewitt
De Soete Consulting BVBA
SPO
Mercer
FAROS Consulting GmbH & Co. KG
Independent Consultant
APK
Coach and Grow
Independent - former CEO of CWPS
PWC
Nora Finn & Associates
Amundi Asset Management
Edhec
IABE
Goris & Partners BV
Asterias
Active Asset Allocation
Willis Towers Watson
Habbel, Pohlig & Partner – Vermögensverwaltung
Neill Hamillton Investment Associates
Kirstein AS
Avida International
Independent Consultant
ICMA Centre, Henley Business School
Asset Advisors
Inderst Advisory
Allenbridge Investment Advisers
Trustee Decisions Limited
Funds-at-Work
Independent - former managing director, Kodak Pension Fund
Kontrapunkt GmbH
KRE - Kloess Real Estate
Aon Hewitt
Kottmann Advisory AG
Prime BV
Willis
Cardano
Carbon Delta 
Lusenti Partners
Independent Consultant
Aon Hewitt - Cyprus - Ltd
Intcap Limited
Capital Cranfield Pension Trustees
GiTeC Prévoyance SA
Fortunis Consultancy
Aon Hewitt
GFMoore Consulting
Moritz Consulting GmbH
Prometea Advisors
Former director at HSBC Pension Scheme
Fixage
Formerly with Amundi Asset Management 
Aon Hewitt
Mercer Consulting
Pusa Consulting Oy
Create-Research 
Harcourt 
Redington
Formerly with PKA 
Camdor Global
Preventable Surprises
Towers Watson
ICMA Centre, Henley Business School
Benefit Advisors Oy
Funds-at-Work
Rivington Pike
Van Nunen & Partners
ESOFAC
Aon Hewitt
Candriam Investors Group 
If you would like to learn more about the judging process or be considered as a judge, please contact: 

Robert Watson
Pension Funds Relationship Manager
robert.watson@ipe.com
+44 (0)20 3465 9327